|
Question 9) What does the term
"invasive plant" mean to you? |
| Survey | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q5 | Q6-7 | Q8 | Q9 |Q10 | Q11 | Q12 | Q13 | Q14 | Q15 | Q16 | Q17 | Q18 | Q19 | Q20 | Q21 | Q22 | Q23-24 | Q25 | Q26-27 | Q28 | Q29 | Q30 |
|
72 participants
chose to respond to Question 9. Their responses included many common themes
which are are shown in the graph, above. 5 respondents either gave me
a definition very similar to ANLA's or simply said that their definition
was the same as ANLA's (one helped write it). One common issue was
whether or not an invasive plant is indigenous. 16 respondents explicitly
stated in their definition that an invasive plant is introduced or non-native
to the place where it invcades. 3/16 wrote "usually non-native"
to allow the possibility of indigenous invasives. On the other hand, 2
respondents felt strongly that an invasive plant could also be native
and included that in their definition (one wrote "native or introduced";
the other wrote "native or cultivated"). 4 more said that invasive
plants escape from their intended, original planting, showing that they
recognize the association with horticultural escapes and invasive species. 22 of the respondents
described plant traits in their definitions. 8 mentioned rapid growth,
11 mentioned rapid spread (it was often ambiguous as to whether they meant
spread of an individual plant or a plant population), 4 described spread
by seed, 2 by vegetative means or roots, and 3 mentioned asexual reproduction. 44 of the respondents
described invasive plants' effects on their surroundings. 16 said that
invasive plants become dominant (or "take over" or "crowds
out") where they have invaded, while 9 called invasive plants "agressive".
16 mentioned that they harm other plants, while 12 specified that they
harm indigenous (native) plants. 2 respondents also mentioned that invasive
plants lack natural methods of control, like competition and predation. 8 respondents mentioned
the effect on managed lands by calling invasive plants "weeds"
(4), or explicitly discussing the cost involved in controlling invasive
plants (4). 2 of the respondents who called invasive plants weeds specifically
called them "noxious weeds", while an additional respondent
called them "noxious and persistently agressive non-native plant[s]".
The use of the term noxious weed may indicate that these respondents associate
their idea of an invasive plant to the regulatory definition of invasive
weeds, which is generally limited to plants that are agricultural pests.
Two of the respondents who used "noxious" also mentioned harm
to other plants in natural systems. One, however, simply wrote "noxious
weed." In addition to the
12 who mentioned that invasive plants harm native plants, 10 mentioned
invasive plants' effects on the environment or ecosystem (2 mentioned
both) and five used the ANLA definition as their own, so 26/72 (36%) respondents
explicitly stated that invasive plants effect an element of biodiversity.
21 respondents discussed
plants on an aesthetic basis by saying that they were undesirable (9)
and/or difficult to control or eradicate (14). Including the respondents
who called invasive plants "weeds", 25/72 (35%) of the respondents
to question 9 discussed invasive plants in relation to human aesthetics
that dictate desirable and undesirable (weedy) plants. Of these 25, 6
also mentioned that invasive plants harm other (4 specified "native")
plants or the ecosystem. 19/72 (26%) defined invasive plants by relating
them to anthropocentric values of desirability without discussing their
effect on natural systems. |
|
Survey | Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | Q5 | Q6-7 | Q8 | Q9 |Q10 | Q11 | Q12 | Q13 | Q14 | Q15 | Q16 | Q17 | Q18 | Q19 | Q20 | Q21 | Q22 | Q23-24 | Q25 | Q26-27 | Q28 | Q29 | Q30 |