Are They Protected?
The Success or Failure of the Worker Protection Standard Regulation in the Lives
and Working Conditions of Oregon's Migrant Farm Workers
Marissa Maier
Objectives:
- (a) To assess the degree of employer compliance with the EPA Worker Protection
Standards (WPS) in four migrant camps and
(b) To assess the exposure of migrant farmworkers to pesticides.
- To evaluate the extent of knowledge migrant farmworkers have of pesticides
(specifically: what pesticides are, what their health effects are, what the
symptoms of exposure are, and how exposure can be prevented).
- To assess the saliency of pesticides to migrant farmworkers.
Methods: I administered a survey to 88 migrant farmworkers in four camps in
the Hillsboro region of Oregon. I obtained frequency distributions and crude
odds ratios using the statistical analysis package SPSS.
Results:
- Work Conditions: The Worker Protection Standards are unevenly complied with
by employers. Specific aspects of the regulations are not as uniformly followed
as others (e.g. workers do appear to be informed by their employer of pesticide
applications but training is not consistently provided).
- Health Conditions: Illness is a prominent occurrence among workers, with
half of the interviewees reporting health problems after working in the fields.
- Knowledge of Pesticides: Knowledge of pesticides is extremely low, indicating
that the WPS are not meeting one of the stated main objectives.
- Saliency of Pesticides: Pesticides are not a primary concern for farmworkers
relative to other issues.
- Groups at Higher Risk: Specific sub-groups were more likely to report non-compliance
with the WPS, indicators of exposure to pesticides, low knowledge of pesticides,
and health problems. These groups are: women, indigenous workers, speakers
of indigenous languages, and particular camps.
Conclusion:
Uneven compliance with the WPS places workers at greater risk of unsafe exposure
to pesticides. The low knowledge and saliency of pesticides decreases the ability
of farmworkers to address work conditions related to pesticide exposure. Government
agencies should be more active in ensuring that owners fully comply with the
WPS. However, the issue of pesticide exposure will not be resolved in the long
term unless the broader dynamics affecting work conditions are addressed, including
the international political and economic structure that creates the need for
migration and the legal inequality between documented and undocumented immigrants.